From cozy cafés and Southern comfort food to fresh seafood and chef-driven bistros, Williamsburg offers a rich and varied dining scene. Whether you’re fueling up after a day of sightseeing, looking for a family-friendly spot, or planning a romantic dinner, you’ll find something to satisfy every craving. Below is a curated list of the top-rated restaurants in and around Williamsburg—each chosen for great reviews, standout menus, and memorable experiences.
Fat Canary
Location: 410 S Nassau Street, Williamsburg, VA
A polished, upscale bistro nested in Colonial Williamsburg’s Merchants Square, Fat Canary serves refined American cuisine with an emphasis on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. With an open kitchen design, an extensive wine list, and standout dishes like grilled beef tenderloin and house-made mozzarella, this contemporary eatery is ideal for special occasions or romantic dinners. Rated around 4.9 stars and consistently a locals’ and visitors’ favorite.
Berret’s Seafood Restaurant & Taphouse Grill
Location: 199 S Boundary Street, Williamsburg, VA
Berret’s is a beloved seafood institution in Merchants Square since 1983, offering a dual-concept: the elegant Seafood Restaurant and the casual Taphouse Grill. Known for fresh oysters, seafood entrees, and a kid-friendly patio with games. Generous portions and friendly service keep families and seafood lovers returning—rated around 4.5 stars on Google.
Amber Ox Public House
Location: 525 Prince George Street, Williamsburg, VA
A modern American gastropub with contemporary décor and a local craft-beer focus (via the Precarious Beer Project). Its menu highlights include oak-smoked wings, shrimp & grits, and a Southern-inspired ham board with house-made biscuits. Boasting a vibrant yet welcoming atmosphere, Amber Ox scores approximately 4.4 stars on Google.
La Tienda Tapas Bar
Location: 1325 Jamestown Road, Williamsburg, VA
An authentic Spanish tapas bar offering an elegant yet lively dining atmosphere. La Tienda Tapas menu includes classic tapas like croquettes, bacon-wrapped dates, clams in cider, and a standout paella. Consistently praised for excellent flavor, presentation, and service, it maintains a 4.5–5 star rating.
Second Street American Bistro
Location: 420 S Boundary Street, Williamsburg, VA
Second Street is an ppscale-casual bistro known for creative American dishes with international twists. The inviting ambiance, along with quality options like signature entrees, small plates, and fresh seafood, makes it a popular dining destination. Spacious and comfortable, it earns around 4.4 stars.
Old Chickahominy House
Location: 1211 Jamestown Road, Williamsburg, VA
A Williamsburg staple, Old Chickahominy House serves up traditional Southern comfort food in a cozy, historic setting. Guests rave about the Brunswick stew, ham biscuits, and hearty breakfasts like Miss Melinda’s Pancakes. With a connected gift shop and a homey, vintage vibe, it’s a great stop for a relaxed meal after exploring the nearby attractions. Perfect for families or anyone looking to enjoy a true taste of Virginia hospitality. Consistently rated around 4.6 stars on Google.
